| a fly | |
| a scottish terrier | |
| pirate hunter | |
| furtive citizen | |
| drunken sailor | |
| traveller | |
| hired thug | |
| shadowy thief | thief's dagger |
| assassin | thief's dagger, cloak of deceit |
| skinny cat | |
| conniving pirate | a red bandana |
| a criminal | a thin rapier |
| a criminal leader | a rocky slab of earth, a stone spear |
| homeless man | |
| Rasputin | a cut gemstone |
| a sailor | Buccaneer's longsword |
| streetwalker | |
| town sheriff | a pair of hard leather boots |
| blue whale | |
| gray dolphin | |
| sea anemone | |
| manta ray | |
| giant octopus | |
| sea horse | |
| hammerhead shark |
| conniving pirate | red bandana, a cutlass, white cloth pants |
| grumpy cook | |
| pirate's captain | a swashbuckler's axe, a pair of bracers, a silver band, a brig key |
| a pirate's hostage | |
| first mate | a pirate's pike, a pair of pirate bracers, a silver band, a brig key |
| a moray eel | |
| lionfish | |
| a Guard of Kraken | stone spear |
| The Kraken | an eye of a Kraken, a Tentacle of the Kraken, a gaudy granite scroll |